Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria

I love local businesses and will support them whole heartily…Tonight WAS NOT IT. Maybe it was a one off, but I will absolutely not be returning.

Below is what we ordered:

Cheese Pizza: 0/10
-This was absolutely gross….idk what they did but the entire Cheese pizza tasted like a cheap tin can that was pulled out of the freezer. Little Ceasers is 10x better and 10x cheaper….

Meatballs: 5/10
-The meatball itself was good, great seasoning, but still had that tin can frozen sauce taste mixed in there.

Wings: 4/10
-I’ve never had a soggy wing before, but tonight was the night, the flavor was actually pretty decent. The wings were SUPER TINYYY. Think of them being fried up then put into the fridge and microwaved before serving.

Strawberry Cheesecake: 0/10
-I’m pretty sure the Strawberry filling was expired and was 100% from a can, couldn’t even eat it.

Regular Cheesecake: 6/10
-The best tasting thing in the whole meal, was actually ok, it tasted like one of those ones youd get from Walmart in the freezer section.

I would absolutely avoid this place. 37th was hyped up so much on Facebook and from peers, only for us to be absolutely disappointed. I would have rather spent my 60 bucks at little ceasers for better food and experience.

The waitstaff is the reedming factor here, they were very polite, nice and even offered to help carry the meal out to my car, they definitely hired great waiters and staff.

AVOID.

We have frequented the local establishment for years. I always order the taco pizza for myself and a second pizza.
The pizzas arrive, the Meat Lovers according to others was great. The first piece of Taco pizza I tried was extremely salty and over seasoned. I thought it was a fluke. The other party eating the pizza with me said it was burning the roof of her mouth. This pizza was ordered with no jalapeños. On examination it was clearly drenched in taco seasoning powder on the crust. The waitress brought over 2 to go boxes when we were about to leave. I made it a point to let her no that we only needed 1. I made her aware that the Taco pizza was not made correctly and was certainly the worst pizza I’ve ever eaten.
She went to talk to the Manager.
I did not ask for a refund.
Not only did the Manager not show up at our table, when I met up with her at the register, she had the audacity to tell me, ” I talked to the head chef, he made that pizza and it was made correctly”
My reply, “No it was not and how would you know, you never bothered to come look at.”
Manager did offer to make another one. I said, “If that was made correctly, I do not want another one.” Manager: “We can leave the taco seasoning off.”
Like what??? A Taco pizza with no taco.. mmmm
I will never return and I do not appreciate the Manager insinuating I’m a liar without even bothering to check on the pizza at our table.

Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria – New Bern, NC
We had an outstanding experience at Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria! The food was absolutely delicious, full of flavor, and everything we ordered came out piping hot. The service was excellent—friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. It’s clear the staff take pride in both their food and their customers. From start to finish, our visit was enjoyable, and we’ll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend for anyone craving great pizza and top-notch service!